• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

WCF

History, politics, and culture articles and forum discussions.

You are here: Home / Topics / Boston Massacre

- By

Boston Massacre

Home › Forums › Early America › Boston Massacre

  • This topic has 7 voices and 14 replies.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
1 2 →
  • Author
    Posts
  • July 31, 2006 at 2:08 am #247 Reply
    Stumpfoot
    Participant

    Was the Boston Massacre really that, a massacre or was it really self defense? It seems from what I have read that Sam Adams and others, including Paul Revere and his famous painting really twisted the facts and turned it into more of a propaganda tool. Imagine yourself as one of those young British soldiers, Theres nine of you including the commander and your being accosted in a foriegn land by hundreds of angry people, screaming insults, brandishing clubs and sticks, throwing rocks and bricks. What would you do?The first shot into the crowd wasnt fired until one of the soldiers was struck with a club and knocked to the ground. Now I don't condone firing weapons into an unarmed crowd ( I use the 'unarmed' loosely as a club can do a good bit of damage as we all know) But at what point point can this be called self defense?Even John Adams, who defended the soldiers and their commander who was accused of ordering the men to fire, thought so.Your thoughts?

    August 1, 2006 at 4:34 pm #5923 Reply
    DonaldBaker
    Participant

    I am of the opinion that the American colonists twisted many things to galvanize support, but that is to be expected of human struggle.  Information is still misreported in our modern techo media, so all the more likely that such dissonance occurred  in the eighteenth-century.

    August 1, 2006 at 11:34 pm #5924 Reply
    Phidippides
    Keymaster

    I am of the opinion that the American colonists twisted many things to galvanize support, but that is to be expected of human struggle.  Information is still misreported in our modern techo media, so all the more likely that such dissonance occurred  in the eighteenth-century.

    That is something that I have wondered about.  I have heard that the Colonists had revolted against the British for less that what Americans put up with today.  Also, from what I understand only 1/3 of the Colonists supported the war against the British.  Is this the perception we get from our historical readings?  How many people died in the Boston Massacre?  I think the number was seven.  While this is undoubtedly sad, I do not know that it qualifies as a “massacre”.  I wonder how much propaganda was in play back then, some of which made it into our history books.

    August 3, 2006 at 3:01 am #5925 Reply
    Stumpfoot
    Participant

    I have read more than once that Sam Adams was the great propagandist and not above a little manipulation as well.

    August 3, 2006 at 3:42 am #5926 Reply
    Phidippides
    Keymaster

    I think when Ben Franklin and Sam Adams (?) went on their trip to France to try to recruit assistance with the War, they played the role of “marketers”.  Ben Franklin went there as a sort of celebrity of his day.  I don't think it's difficult to see why they'd have a celebrity try to drum up support for the Colonists' cause.

    August 3, 2006 at 4:17 am #5927 Reply
    Stumpfoot
    Participant

    Actually it was John Adams who went. It's kind of funny when you read about it, they were kind of like the odd couple.

    August 18, 2006 at 10:05 pm #5928 Reply
    Phidippides
    Keymaster

    Oh, ok, John Adams.  Yes, “The Odd Couple” goes to Paris….it would make for a good dramatic comedy if made into a movie.  :-)I recently saw a History Channel show that said Franklin was in Paris for five years…I believe all the way up to the surrender of the British….so Franklin was able to negotiate the peace treaty without really travelling very far. 

    August 19, 2006 at 12:11 am #5929 Reply
    Stumpfoot
    Participant

    I recently saw a History Channel show that said Franklin was in Paris for five years

    Yes, ole Ben was quite the celebrity in London town.

    February 10, 2007 at 6:11 pm #5930 Reply
    H.H. Buggfuzz
    Participant

    Apparently Ben just left his family and was partying in France for five years.  He was quite the ladies man  by all accounts

    February 26, 2007 at 8:16 am #5931 Reply
    Stumpfoot
    Participant

    Some say he had an affair (never proven) with the lady he rented a room from in her boarding house.

    November 24, 2008 at 8:39 pm #5932 Reply
    HistoryFan
    Participant

    Revere's depiction of the Boston Massacre was full of inaccuracies which leads me to believe it was created primarily for propaganda purposes.  First of all the picture makes it look like it was day time when the events acctually occured.  In fact it was 9:00pm in early March.  I doubt it was the street lights that illuminated the area.  Also, eye witnesses indicated there was snow on the ground and in fact the colonists were throwing showballs or chunks of ice at the British soldiers.  The depiction doesn't even show the colonists with clubs which were reported by the eye witnesses.  Finally, the picture shows Prescott behind the soldiers rather than in front as the eye witness accounts indicate.  All this information was available at the time so my guess is that Revere wasn't trying all that hard to be accurate.  He was more interested in making a point.

    November 25, 2008 at 3:39 am #5933 Reply
    Wally
    Participant

    Read Drinker-Bowman's bio of Adams… Paul was the king of propaganda… not even there! Good copy but very skewed.

    November 25, 2008 at 4:14 am #5934 Reply
    DonaldBaker
    Participant

    The entire Revolution was based on propaganda and fear mongering (note I'm not absolving the British in any way here).  We must be honest with ourselves about our Revolution.  It was a generated conflict designed to get us away from British control because we wanted to control our own destiny once we felt we were self sufficient enough to manage things on our own…which only happened after the Seven Years War.  With the French and their Indian allies defeated, the North American continent became “safe” and the need for British protection no longer necessary.  The best analogy is how teenagers gain independence after they've gotten a taste of adulthood.  The American colonies were no different than rebellious teenagers wanting to prove they were adults.

    December 8, 2008 at 8:50 pm #5935 Reply
    Stumpfoot
    Participant

    Man has been doing it for eon's.

    January 1, 2009 at 6:47 pm #5936 Reply
    CaptDreyfus
    Participant

    The Boston Massacre was a cleverly and very well executed propoganda movement. Revere's depiction is at the helm of that movement.

  • Author
    Posts
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
1 2 →
Reply To: Boston Massacre
Your information:




Primary Sidebar

Login

Log In
Register Lost Password

Blog Categories

Search blog articles

Before Footer

  • Did Julian the Apostate’s plan ever have a chance?

    Julian the Apostate stands as an enigmatic figure among Roman emperors, ascending to power in 361 AD …

    Read More

    Did Julian the Apostate’s plan ever have a chance?
  • The Babylonian Bride

    Marriage customs in Ancient Babylon Ancient Babylonia was a society, which, although it did not …

    Read More

    The Babylonian Bride
  • The fall of Athens

    In 407 B.C. and again in 405 B.C.. the Spartans in alliance with their old enemies, the Persians, …

    Read More

    The fall of Athens

Footer

Posts by topic

2016 Election Alexander Hamilton American Revolution archaeology Aristotle Ben Franklin Black Americans Charles Dickens Christianity Christmas Constantine Custer's Last Stand Egypt email engineering England forum security Founding Fathers France future history George Washington Germany Greece hacker Hitler Industrial Revolution Ireland James Madison Jewish medieval military history Paleolithic philosophy pilgrimage Rome Russia SEO Slavery Socrates spammer technology Trump World War I World War II Year In Review

Recent Topics

  • Midsummer Night: June 25th
  • Testing out a new feature
  • Did Julian the Apostate’s plan ever have a chance?
  • Release of the JFK Files
  • What was the greatest military advancement of all time?

RSS Ancient News

Recent Forum Replies

  • Going to feature old posts
  • What’s new?
  • Testing out a new feature
  • Testing out a new feature
  • Testing out a new feature

Copyright © 2025 · Contact

Insert/edit link

Enter the destination URL

Or link to existing content

    No search term specified. Showing recent items. Search or use up and down arrow keys to select an item.